In-Home Cat Sitting in Brooklyn, NY

We match cat owners across Brooklyn, NY with experienced, background-checked sitters who care for your cat in the comfort of their own home, providing feeding, litter box care, playtime, and medication.

Looking for dog care?

We also offer professional dog sitting and private dog walking.
Explore NYC Area Dog Care

Cat Sitting Options in Brooklyn

Choose the level of care that fits your cat and schedule—from quick visits to full-time care at home.

Drop-In Cat Visits

30, 45, or 60-minute visits for feeding, litter cleaning, playtime, and more.

Extended Daytime Cat Care

2-8 hour visits for cats who need more daytime companionship.

Overnight Cat Sitting

10 or 12 hour overnight stays to maintain your cat’s nighttime routine.

24-Hour Live-In House Sitting

Live-in care for cats who need constant presence and supervision.

Every Visit Includes

Receive Daily Visit Updates

Photo Updates

Fresh Food & Water

Litter Box Cleaning

Playtime & Affection

Medication Administration

Home Check-In

Why Brooklyn Cat Owners Choose The Comforted Kitty

Professional, in-home cat care designed to keep routines consistent while you’re away.

Cat-Only Focus

Sitters who specialize in cats and understand feline behavior, stress signals, and routines.

Receive Daily Visit Updates

Updates After Every Visit

Receive visit updates with photos after each visit, so you always know how your cat is doing.

Routines Stay Consistent

Feeding, litter cleaning, and care follow your cat’s normal schedule as closely as possible.

Vetted, Insured Sitters

Background-checked, insured sitters selected for reliability, professionalism, and cat care experience.

Neighborhoods We Serve in Brooklyn

North

  • Williamsburg
  • Greenpoint
  • Bushwick

Central

  • Prospect Heights
  • Crown Heights
  • Fort Greene
  • Clinton Hill

South

  • Park Slope
  • Gowanus
  • Carroll Gardens
  • Cobble Hill

East / West:

  • Bedford-Stuyvesant
  • Flatbush
  • Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Brooklyn Cat Sitting Reviews

Real feedback from Brooklyn clients who trust our sitters to care for their cats at home.

My regular cat sitter was not able to watch Tux for a trip and I started to panic. My girlfriend found The Comforted Kitty and my sitter was amazing. She's an amazing cat person and really cares about taking care of your little furry. Love the photos and updates while I am gone! Will be using this service for all future needs.
Matt N.
Brooklyn, NY
"Our clowder of five cats have bonded with our sitter quickly and happily greet her at the door! She always sends the best pictures/updates to us through the Time to Pet App and text. Five stars, customers for life. Thank you for all your help!"
Jordan W.
Brooklyn, NY
"Our sitter communicated daily in detail, with pictures, identified possible concerns (one of our cats has health problems), and responded promptly to any communications from us. When we got home after 5 days away all was in order, the cats were happy and well fed, and everything was tidy. We couldn't have asked for more."
Chris T.
Brooklyn, NY

Meet Your Brooklyn Cat Sitters

You’ll always meet your sitter in person before your booking.

Caitlin M Brooklyn NY cat sitter
Caitlin M.

Professional Cat Sitter in Brooklyn, NY

Kelly G Brooklyn ny cat sitter
Kelly G.

Professional Cat Sitter in Brooklyn, NY

Why Cats Stay Happier at Home

For many cats, staying home helps reduce stress and keeps daily routines more consistent while you’re away.

  • Keep feeding, litter box, and daily routines consistent
  • Stay in familiar surroundings
  • Avoid stressful travel and sudden environmental changes
  • Skip exposure to unfamiliar animals
  • Receive comforting, one-on-one attention at home

Who In-Home Cat Sitting Works Best For

In-home cat sitting works especially well for:

Apartment & Condo Cats

Minimal disruption in smaller, high-density living environments.

Frequent Travelers

Reliable care while you’re away for work trips, vacations, or regular travel.

Senior Cats

Gentle care focused on your cat’s routine.

Cats with Medical Needs

Support for medications and special care routines.

Indoor-Only Cats

Avoids travel stress and exposure to unfamiliar environments.

Multi-Cat Households

Individualized care for feeding, litter, and attention.

How Cat Sitting Works in Brooklyn

Step 1 — Request Cat Sitting

Submit your dates, location, and care details. We confirm availability and match you with a local sitter.

Step 2 — Meet Your Sitter

Schedule a free in-home Meet & Greet to review your cat’s routine, care instructions, and home access.

Step 3 — Travel with Peace of Mind

Your sitter follows your instructions and cares for your cat at home. You receive updates with photos after each visit.

Dog Sitting & Walking in Brooklyn

The Comforted Kitty also provides professional in-home dog sitting and private dog walking.

Dog Sitting

Personalized drop-in visits, extended daytime care, overnight stays, and live-in house sitting for dogs who are most comfortable at home.

Private Dog Walking

One-on-one walks tailored to your dog’s routine, exercise needs, walking pace, and handling requirements. We do not combine unfamiliar client dogs into group walks.

Care for Cats and Dogs

Have both cats and dogs at home? Tell us about every pet in your household, and we’ll match you with a qualified caregiver.

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to common questions about cat sitting in Brooklyn.

Our sitters serve most neighborhoods throughout Brooklyn. Coverage can vary by sitter, so if you’re unsure whether your address is included, submit a request and we’ll confirm availability before booking.

Yes. Many of our sitters have experience with senior cats, special routines, and vet-prescribed medications (such as pills and liquids). Your sitter will review all care details in advance to ensure your cat’s needs are handled correctly.

All sitters are hand-selected, background-checked, insured, and bonded. The Comforted Kitty also stands behind every booking with a satisfaction guarantee, so you’re not relying on an unverified individual.

Your sitter follows the emergency plan you instruct in your Time to Pet portal and reviewed at the Meet & Greet, including contacting you and your designated emergency contacts. If needed, they’ll seek veterinary care using your preferred vet or the nearest appropriate clinic.

We recommend booking as soon as you know your dates—especially for holidays or longer trips. Last-minute requests are sometimes possible, but availability varies by sitter and time of year.

Have a question? We’re happy to help.

Book Trusted Cat Sitting in Brooklyn

Travel knowing your cat can stay comfortable at home with professional in-home care. Free Meet & Greet included.